Wednesday, May 4, 2011

"OSAMA IS DEAD."

That was the status update that woke me up from idle procrastination on Tuesday 2 May. I was shocked and quickly opened more tabs to find out the story. Information overload. So many sources, so much information, and so many missing links?. OK so there was a shoot out. His body was what? Dumped into the water so that his burial site could not be worshiped as a shrine. And so the conspiracies begin. In Obama's speech he noted that is was great day for America,  that is was a great day for justice, and that the world was now a safer place. American youths rejoiced and celebrated this fact.

After the devastation of 9/11 one can only imagine how they wanted to see some resolvent to there horrific attack. But the way it was announced and celebrated with all the excitement and spectacle i couldn't help but feel a little nauseous  from all the hype. Its not that Osama isn't a terrible person for the attacks, that they were not both horrific and appalling. I just don't understand how the soldiers can go in there and kill him, choose to do with the body, and then celebrate it. I just seems a bit barbaric to me and the sort of behavior that sets a bad example for the other nations and people. Shouldn't 1st world countries, with all out resources and "intellect" be able to resolve things in a more reserved manner. If even the richest and most powerful countries are executing people at free-will what hope is there for other countries to adhere to some sort of judicial system?

I read Peter Bergens article, which bought to my attention that Al-Qaeda was actually Bin-Ladens creation. I hope that this does shut down future Al-Qaeda operation, but unfortunately I don't think it is quite that simple, and seeing lately that there have been revenge attacks in Pakistan, I fear that things maybe getting worse.

Albert Mohler raises the point that Americans should be celebrating that fact that, the leader of Al-Qaeda is gone, they should technically be in a safer place, but society should not be celebrating the actual death. Although I can only imagine that if Bin Laden was planning more attacks, he would have had people underneath him in Al Qaeda also capable of planning attacks on America. Mohler states "The death of bin Laden was fully justified as an act of war, but not as an act of justice"

I see that many Americans who lost people in 9/11 may feel that this death has bought them closer to justice. But does taking one mans life provide justice? It seems like a never ending cycle of blood spilled and I don't think it will equate to justice whether he is dead or not. When looking at the celebrations in the streets of America, it is evident that they are celebrating a death. For a country that preaches christian values to the extent that they still has many anti- abortion activists, I find this whole situation quite hypocritical. I wonder how Jesus would feel about the war on terror?

I hope that Americans do feel some sort of closure out of this, after the emotional trauma that many families and friends would have feel after 9/11. I realise that I have used the term American quite broadly, and that it they would have had mixed reactions to it, just like we do here in New Zealand. After 9/11 America did need to do something, and a trial in New York maybe a little unrealistic. I just don't feel that the world is really a safer place, or that justice really has been served. I think that America media should not be labeling this execution as justice. An execution is an execution.  

11 comments:

  1. I completely agree with you Rachel, I think its entirely disgusting the way in which the American government can just go in and kill Osama Bin Laden. He obviously was innocent in no way but shouldn’t his punishment and perhaps assassination of this man be in the hands of his own government? Bin Laden was a terrorist or some may say realist/freedom fighter, he committed many hate crimes against America and I can understand why people were rejoicing over his death but what was horrible was the fact that they put a picture of his murdered bloody face on the news! America isn’t innocent and its about time they know what there government is actually doing to other country’s and hold themselves accountable for the terrorist acts.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Rachel, thank god someone has the same opinions as me. I was disgusted when I saw this on the news. Since when has it been okay to publicly assassinate someone by the government / soldiers etc. They have been chasing Bin Laden for so long and they just kill him like that, why not keep him and interrogate him, or torture him would most likely be the case as the American government is so corrupt. Fair enough that he was behind all the terrorist attacks and lots of innocent people were killed, your right they (American government) are being hypocritical by killing as well. I'm not sure if I fully understood how this raid happened it was not very clear. Nothing was mentioned about how many other people may have gotten caught up in misfire etc. And putting the picture of Bin Laden on the news with out blurring out was absolutely revolting. I am appalled that our NZ news producers would even allow this on NZ TV.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think you have to be American to appreciate it. Those who were involved in that war or lost someone because of Osama would have a very different view point even though it's a far cry from justice some people may find closure that he no longer exists. In response to the conspiracy of his body being dumped in the ocean. There are heaps of conspiracies out there like the moon landing etc. It's not worth anyones time getting hung up on it because there is nothing that anyone can do about it. We can also say America should do this and that however if people have time to worry about America they should take a good look at our own government and direct some attention there because that is where it matters.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hmm I do agree that i would have to be American to understand the emotions behind it and need for closure. Although I do think it is important to look at what other countries to do, because we can look at other countries objectivly, it gives greater insight in dealing with our own issues and helps to see things from a different point of view. I also think that people focus on America alot, not so much because of government issues but as an indication of where culture is and where culture is going. America media has a huge presence in New Zealand, we watch so much American television and films so I dont see why we wouldnt be interested in their issues. I do agree with you that focusing on our own country would be more beneficial as focusing on America in a pratical sense.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I totally agree with the view point presented here. The whole thing was very uncivilized. Americans aren't the Heros when they call this justice. More humanly measures could have been taken.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Conspiracy or not, Osama Bin Laden was responsible for killing thousands. Suzana, were more humanly measures taken when Osama, as the head of Al Queda, killed thousands of people in his terriost attacks? We all remember where we were when the twin towers fell. We've all seen what he's capable of so there's no denying he's a monster. Osama was never going to give himself up. If he was innocent he would have never gone into hiding. I'm sick of everyone jumping on the 'I hate America' bandwagon. Imagine if America had not launched there their war against terror? What message would that send? That terrioism was ok? This man represented terror. To be honest, I'm glad he's dead. And I think all those families that lost loved ones would agree with me. The world is now a safer place. Go America.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I am not against America for that its just the world is not a safer place. There could be heaps of his followers still plotting. Doesn't this just make it even worse.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Why the United States may have the right to kill Osama bin Laden does, the kill bin Laden, I think this is not a ending of the issue, it is just another beginning of issue. Because may be some members of AL-Qaeda will strike back USA. Hope that Obama should be prepared for it, how to protect the United States in the future.

    ReplyDelete
  9. This is just another example of American policy towards other countries and has been going on for years. And I dont know why the rest of the world listened and believed whatever the American government says. Who really are the terrorists?
    It is a known fact that Bin Laden was trained by CIA. And the world has been led to believe that it was Bin Laden who turned bad.

    Sadam Husain had been killing, torturing and chemical bombing thousands of innocent people since 1981. But the world only got to hear about Sadam Husain when he turned his back on America and invaded Kuwait in 1990. Suddenly the world viewed Sadam as the bad guy and became Americas target.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I cannot say U.S did right things but if it is my case, I also want to kill murdered if I know who killed my friends or parents. But as I said it is "If". I wanted to kill but I will not. Because I will become same people if i kill somebody. So... my opinion is U.S did not do right things but I will not blame them..

    ReplyDelete
  11. (also want to kill murdered if I know who killed my friends or parents.)murdered- murderer :( sorry for mistyping

    ReplyDelete